Sorry to hear your blush wast busted up. I hope they do send you a new one. I did log in and picked the darker shade blush for AugustI got the same box as MSA did but my blush was busted.
Glossy said they are sending a replacement. I already bought this blush compact with two blushes from wantable makeup before, I wish I knew I was getting one from glossybox. But my GB was "free" with the 500 dots they gave me for my birthday/customer loyalty.
Did you guys log on to your account and select your blush color for August?