Kelli
I'm Not Bill Gates, I'm Not Paris Hilton
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2013
- Messages
- 1,165
- Reaction score
- 817
I have that one and just started using it again to try and use it up and ugh. It has not held up well. The tip is super frayed and it smears off my eyes within 20 minutes. Good to hear the other one is better. i think I liked the 2013 one more when I first got it, so I wasn't sure if it just has kind of gone bad or what.awww sucks that you dont like black eyeliner but you should totally get one of the other colors because it is a great formula, and stays on super well for a very long time. No matter the marketing of long lasting eyeliner, my eyes/eyelids well get me too look like a girl who has been balling for 5 hours... this one has stood the test of time. It is not like the eyeliner pen that we got a year ago in their 2013 Anniversary box.